Biology · Photosynthesis in Higher Plants · NEET
They are different structures with different jobs. Grana are stacks of flat membrane sacs (thylakoids) inside the chloroplast; this is where the light reaction happens and ATP + NADPH are made. Stroma is the colourless fluid (matrix) surrounding the grana; this is where the dark reaction (Calvin cycle) fixes CO2 into sugar. Short rule: grana = light reaction, stroma = dark reaction. For NEET, do not mix up 'stroma' (the fluid) with 'stroma lamellae' (membrane tubes).
A thylakoid is a single flat, disc-shaped membrane sac. Many thylakoids stack up like a pile of coins to form a granum (plural: grana). The flat membrane sheets that connect one granum to another are called stroma lamellae (or intergranal lamellae). So thylakoid = one sac, granum = a stack of thylakoids, lamellae = the bridges joining stacks. The space inside a thylakoid is the thylakoid lumen.
The light reaction (photochemical phase) takes place on the thylakoid membranes of the grana, because the pigments, photosystems and ATP synthase sit there. The dark reaction (biosynthetic phase / Calvin cycle) takes place in the stroma, the fluid part, because the enzyme RuBisCO and the CO2-fixing enzymes are dissolved there. NCERT calls this 'a clear division of labour within the chloroplast.'
Grana lamellae are the stacked thylakoids inside the grana and carry BOTH Photosystem I (PS I) and Photosystem II (PS II), plus NADP reductase, so they can do non-cyclic photophosphorylation and make NADPH. Stroma lamellae are the unstacked membranes connecting grana; they carry ONLY PS I and lack PS II and NADP reductase, so they cannot split water or make NADPH. This exact point was tested in NEET 2019/2021.
The thylakoid lumen (the space inside the thylakoid) has the highest number of protons and the lowest pH. Reason: water is split on the inner side of the thylakoid membrane and the H+ released collects inside the lumen, and more protons are pumped in during electron transport. This proton build-up drives ATP synthase (chemiosmosis). NEET 2016 asked exactly this.
In a chloroplast the highest number of protons are found in:
Which of the following statements is incorrect?
Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.
No. Stroma is the colourless fluid matrix that fills the chloroplast and holds the Calvin cycle enzymes. Stroma lamellae are flat membrane tubes that connect one granum to the next and carry only PS I. Same word 'stroma', totally different structures.
A thylakoid is one flat membrane sac. A granum is a stack of many thylakoids piled like coins. One chloroplast can have 40 to 60 grana, each with 5 to 25 thylakoids.
NCERT states there is a 'division of labour'. The membrane system (grana + stroma lamellae) traps light energy and makes ATP and NADPH. The stroma uses that ATP and NADPH to fix CO2 into sugar and starch.
Because water splitting dumps protons into the lumen, giving it the most H+ and lowest pH. This proton gradient across the thylakoid membrane powers ATP synthase. It is a repeat NEET point (2016).
No. Stroma lamellae have only PS I and lack PS II and NADP reductase, so they cannot split water or reduce NADP+. NADPH is made on the grana thylakoids during non-cyclic photophosphorylation.