Why 4s Fills Before 3d (and Empties First) — 3d Transition Series

Chemistry · Periodic Classification Of Properties · NEET

The 4s orbital fills before 3d because, for empty atoms, 4s has slightly LOWER energy than 3d. You find this using the (n + l) rule: for 4s, (4 + 0) = 4, and for 3d, (3 + 2) = 5. Lower total wins, so 4s fills first. Memory hook: "4s enters first, but leaves first too" — during ionisation the 4s electrons are removed before 3d.
Filling order: (n + l) rule — smaller value fills first4sn+l = 4+0 = 43dn+l = 3+2 = 5fills 1stFilling: 4s first → then 3d (Sc = [Ar] 3d¹ 4s²)Ionisation: 4s removed FIRST (Fe → Fe²⁺ loses 4s²)Memory: enters first, but leaves first too.
The (n + l) rule: 4s (n+l = 4) has lower energy than 3d (n+l = 5), so 4s fills first — but once 3d is filled it drops lower, so 4s electrons are removed first during ionisation.

Your doubts, answered

Why does 4s fill before 3d if 3 is smaller than 4?

Because filling order depends on total ENERGY, not just the shell number n. Energy is compared using the (n + l) rule. For 4s: n=4, l=0, so n+l = 4. For 3d: n=3, l=2, so n+l = 5. The orbital with the smaller (n + l) value has lower energy and fills first. So 4s (=4) fills before 3d (=5), even though the shell number 4 looks bigger than 3.

What is the (n + l) rule and how do I use it for 4s and 3d?

For each orbital, add the principal quantum number n and the azimuthal quantum number l (s=0, p=1, d=2, f=3). Fill the orbital with the LOWER (n + l) first. If two orbitals have the same (n + l), fill the one with the smaller n first. 4s = 4 + 0 = 4. 3d = 3 + 2 = 5. Since 4 is less than 5, 4s fills first. This is why the 3d transition series appears in period 4, after 4s is already filled at K and Ca.

If 4s fills before 3d, why is it removed first during ionisation?

This is the part most students miss. Once 3d starts to fill, the 3d electrons pull closer to the nucleus and 3d actually drops slightly BELOW 4s in energy. So in a filled transition atom, 4s is now the higher, outer orbital. When you form an ion (like Fe to Fe2+), the outermost, highest-energy electrons leave first — that is the 4s electrons. Rule to remember: fill 4s first, but remove 4s first.

Why is scandium 3d1 4s2 and not 3d3?

Scandium (Z = 21) fills 4s completely first because 4s is lower in energy for the neutral atom. Potassium and calcium already filled 4s to 4s2 (that is why period 4 starts with them). Then the 21st electron goes into 3d, giving [Ar] 3d1 4s2. It is NOT 3d3, because 4s must be filled before 3d gets three electrons. This filling pattern is exactly what NCERT states: 'the fourth period starts at potassium, the added electrons fill up the 4s orbital, and before 4p is filled, filling up of 3d becomes energetically favourable.'

Where does the 3d transition series start and end?

It starts at scandium, Sc (Z = 21), with configuration [Ar] 3d1 4s2, and ends at zinc, Zn (Z = 30), with [Ar] 3d10 4s2. Across these 10 elements the five 3d orbitals fill up. After 3d is full, the 4p orbitals fill (Ga to Kr) and period 4 ends at krypton. Remember: 3d holds a maximum of 10 electrons, which is why the first transition series has exactly 10 elements.

Are Cr and Cu exceptions to the 4s-before-3d rule?

Yes. Chromium is [Ar] 3d5 4s1 (not 3d4 4s2) and copper is [Ar] 3d10 4s1 (not 3d9 4s2). One 4s electron shifts into 3d because a half-filled (d5) or completely filled (d10) 3d set is extra stable (symmetry + exchange energy). The general 4s-before-3d rule still holds; Cr and Cu are just the two famous exceptions NEET loves to ask.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Since the shell number 3 is smaller than 4, the 3d orbital must fill before 4s, so scandium should be [Ar] 3d3.
Filling order uses the (n + l) rule, not just n. 4s (n+l = 4) is lower than 3d (n+l = 5), so 4s fills first. Scandium is [Ar] 3d1 4s2. In NEET 2025, a configuration like [Ar] 3d3 4s2 is vanadium (a d-block transition element), which you can only identify correctly if you know 4s filled before 3d.
🧠 Small n does not mean fills first — add n + l. 4s beats 3d because 4 < 5.

Real NEET questions

2025

Which among the following electronic configurations belong to main group elements? A. [Ne]3s1 B. [Ar]3d3 4s2 C. [Kr]4d10 5s2 5p5 D. [Ar]3d10 4s1 E. [Rn]5f0 6d2 7s2

A · D and E only
B · A, C and D only
C · B and E only
D · A and C only
Solution: Main group = s-block + p-block. A = [Ne]3s1 is Na (s-block, main group). C = [Kr]4d10 5s2 5p5 is I (p-block, main group). To read these configurations you must know 4s/5s filled before 3d/4d. B = [Ar]3d3 4s2 is V and D = [Ar]3d10 4s1 is Cu — both d-block transition (NOT main group). E = Th is inner-transition. So the main group set is A and C, matching option D. (The concept being tested: 4s fills before 3d, and transition-series configs are written 3d then 4s.)

Solved Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 28 Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Why Elements in the Same Group Have the Same Valence ConfigurationKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Is 4s always lower in energy than 3d?

No. For empty (neutral) atoms before 3d starts filling, 4s is lower, so it fills first. But once 3d is occupied, 3d drops below 4s, which is why 4s electrons are removed first in ions like Fe2+ and Ti3+.

What is the electronic configuration of the first transition element?

Scandium, Sc (Z = 21), is [Ar] 3d1 4s2. It is the first element of the 3d transition series.

Why is the 3d series in period 4 and not period 3?

Because 3d fills only after 4s, which belongs to period 4 (K and Ca). By the (n + l) rule 4s (=4) fills before 3d (=5), so the 3d block physically appears in the fourth period.

How many elements are in the 3d transition series?

Ten, from scandium (Z = 21) to zinc (Z = 30), because the five 3d orbitals hold a maximum of 10 electrons.

Do I write 3d before or after 4s in the configuration?

Standard NCERT/NEET practice writes 3d before 4s (for example [Ar] 3d1 4s2), grouping electrons by shell number. But remember 4s was actually filled first and is removed first.