Comparing a Circuit Connected to AC vs DC Source

Physics · Alternating Current · NEET

On a DC source, only resistance R limits the current, because at zero frequency the inductor acts like a plain wire (X_L = 0) and the capacitor acts like a break in the wire (blocks DC). On an AC source, the current is limited by the full impedance Z = sqrt(R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2), which is always bigger than or equal to R. Memory hook: "DC sees only R, AC sees Z; a capacitor stops DC, an inductor stops fast AC."
Same series R-L circuit, two different sourcesDC12VR=30L (X_L=0)Only R mattersI = 12/30 = 0.4 AAC 12VR=30L (X_L>0)Z = 60 > RI = 12/60 = 0.2 A
The same R-L circuit gives 0.4 A on DC (only R = 30 ohm limits it) but only 0.2 A on AC (impedance Z = 60 ohm limits it), because the inductor blocks AC but not DC. This is the NEET 2019 result.

Your doubts, answered

Why does the same circuit carry more current on DC than on AC?

On DC the frequency is zero, so the inductor's reactance X_L = 2 pi f L becomes zero. It behaves like an ordinary wire and does nothing to limit current, so only R matters and current I = V/R is large. On AC, the inductor adds reactance X_L, making the total opposition Z = sqrt(R^2 + X_L^2) larger than R. A bigger opposition means a smaller current, so I = V/Z is smaller on AC.

Does a capacitor allow DC current to flow?

No. A capacitor blocks steady DC. When you connect DC, the capacitor charges up until its voltage equals the source, and then the current stops (steady current = 0). Its DC reactance X_C = 1/(2 pi f C) becomes infinite at f = 0, like an open switch. But on AC the voltage keeps reversing, so the capacitor keeps charging and discharging and AC current does flow. This is the key clue in the NEET 2019 question.

Why is impedance Z always greater than or equal to resistance R?

Impedance is Z = sqrt(R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2). Because the reactance term is squared and added under the root, Z can never be smaller than R. Z equals R only in two cases: a pure resistor, or at resonance where X_L = X_C cancel out. This is why the AC current I = V/Z is never larger than the DC current I = V/R for the same circuit and same voltage magnitude.

How do I tell whether a hidden circuit has an inductor or a capacitor?

Check if steady DC current flows. If DC current flows (non-zero), there is NO capacitor in series, because a capacitor would block DC completely. If DC current is zero, a capacitor is present. Then compare: R = V_dc / I_dc gives the resistance, and Z = V_ac / I_ac gives the impedance. If Z > R and DC current flows, the extra element is an inductor (series LR).

⚠️ The NEET trap
Students see the same 12 V source and assume the current must be the same, or they include a capacitor even though a steady DC current is flowing.
The current magnitude depends on frequency. DC current uses only R, AC current uses Z. If a steady DC current flows, a series capacitor is impossible because it blocks DC completely.
🧠 Steady DC current flowing = no series capacitor. Z bigger than R with DC flowing = there is an inductor.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2019

A circuit when connected to an AC source of 12 V gives a current of 0.2 A. The same circuit when connected to a DC source of 12 V gives a current of 0.4 A. The circuit is:

A · series LR
B · series RC
C · series LC
D · series LCR
Solution: Step 1: On DC, only resistance limits current. R = V/I = 12 / 0.4 = 30 ohm. Step 2: On AC, the total opposition is impedance. Z = V/I = 12 / 0.2 = 60 ohm. Step 3: Since Z (60) is greater than R (30), a reactive element is present. Step 4: A steady DC current of 0.4 A actually flows, so there is NO capacitor (a capacitor blocks DC). Therefore the reactive element must be an inductor. The circuit is a series LR. Check: Z^2 = R^2 + X_L^2, so 60^2 = 30^2 + X_L^2, giving X_L = 30 sqrt(3) ohm.

Solved Alternating Current NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 27 Alternating Current NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: TransformerKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Alternating Current NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What is the main difference between a circuit on AC and on DC?

On DC, current is limited only by resistance R (I = V/R), because the inductor's reactance is zero and the capacitor blocks steady DC. On AC, current is limited by the full impedance Z = sqrt(R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2), so the same circuit usually carries less current on AC than on DC.

Why does a pure inductor allow full DC but limits AC?

Inductive reactance is X_L = 2 pi f L. At DC the frequency f = 0, so X_L = 0 and the inductor is just a wire. As frequency rises, X_L rises, so it opposes AC more. At very high frequency an inductor almost blocks the current.

Why does a capacitor block DC but pass AC?

Capacitive reactance is X_C = 1/(2 pi f C). At DC (f = 0), X_C is infinite, so no steady current flows. On AC the capacitor keeps charging and discharging as the voltage reverses, so AC current flows, and X_C is smaller at higher frequency.

For the same voltage, is AC current always less than DC current?

Yes, for the same circuit and same voltage magnitude, because Z is always greater than or equal to R. AC current equals DC current only when the circuit is a pure resistor or at resonance (X_L = X_C), where Z = R.