Net Force on a Loop Placed Near a Long Straight Wire

Physics · Moving Charges And Magnetism · NEET

A rectangular or square loop near a long straight wire feels a NET force because the two loop sides parallel to the wire sit at different distances, so they feel unequal forces. The near side (closer, stronger force) and the far side (farther, weaker force) point opposite ways, so the loop is pulled toward the wire if its near current is parallel to the wire current, and pushed away if antiparallel. The two sides perpendicular to the wire give equal and opposite forces that cancel. Memory hook: "Near wins, far loses — net force follows the near side."
Iwirecurrent inearfarF_near (big, pull)F_far (small, push)L3LNet = F_near - F_far= mu0 I i/2pi - mu0 I i/6pi= 2 mu0 I i / (3 pi) (toward wire)Top and bottom sides cancel
Only the loop sides parallel to the wire give a net force: the near side is pulled strongly, the far side pushed weakly, so the net force is toward the wire. The top and bottom (perpendicular) sides cancel.

Your doubts, answered

Why is the net force NOT zero, even though the field is not uniform?

The wire's field B = mu0*I/(2*pi*r) gets weaker as distance r grows. The loop's near side sits in a stronger field than the far side, so it feels a bigger force. The two forces point opposite ways but are unequal, so they do not fully cancel. A net force is left, always directed toward the stronger (near) side.

Which sides of the loop actually give the net force?

Only the two sides parallel to the wire. For a side parallel to the wire, the whole side is at one fixed distance r, so its force = (mu0*I*i)/(2*pi*r) * L is clean and easy. The near side and far side are at different r, so their forces differ, and that difference is the net force.

Why do the two perpendicular sides cancel?

On a side perpendicular to the wire, every small piece is at a different distance, but the top perpendicular side and the bottom perpendicular side are mirror images carrying current in opposite directions. Their force contributions are equal in size and opposite in direction, so they add to zero. You can ignore them for the net force.

How do I decide attraction or repulsion?

Use the parallel-wire rule on the NEAR side only, because it dominates. Parallel currents attract, antiparallel currents repel. If the near side of the loop carries current in the same direction as the wire, the loop is pulled toward the wire; if opposite, it is pushed away.

In NEET 2016 why were distances L and 3L used?

In that figure the near side of the square (side L) is at distance L from the wire, and since the square has side L, the far side is one more square-width away, at L + L... but the marked geometry places the near side at L and far side at 3L. Then F_near = mu0*I*i/(2*pi) and F_far = mu0*I*i/(6*pi), giving net = 2*mu0*I*i/(3*pi). Always read the figure distances; do not assume they are r and 2r.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Adding the forces on all four sides, or treating the perpendicular sides as if they also give a net pull toward the wire.
Only the two sides parallel to the wire matter. The two perpendicular sides give equal and opposite forces that cancel exactly, so net force = F(near side) - F(far side), directed toward the near side.
🧠 Perpendicular sides cancel; parallel sides fight and the near one wins.

Real NEET questions

2016

A square loop ABCD carrying a current i is placed near and coplanar with a long straight conductor XY carrying a current I. The net force on the loop will be:

A · 2 mu0 I i / (3*pi)
B · mu0 I i / (2*pi)
C · 2 mu0 I i L / (3*pi)
D · mu0 I i L / (2*pi)
Solution: Only the two square sides parallel to XY give a net force; the two perpendicular sides cancel. Force per parallel side = (mu0*I*i)/(2*pi) * (L / distance), where L is the side length. From the figure the near side is at distance L and the far side at 3L. Near side: F1 = (mu0*I*i)/(2*pi) * (L/L) = mu0*I*i/(2*pi), attractive. Far side: F2 = (mu0*I*i)/(2*pi) * (L/3L) = mu0*I*i/(6*pi), repulsive. Net force = F1 - F2 = mu0*I*i/(2*pi) - mu0*I*i/(6*pi) = (3 - 1)*mu0*I*i/(6*pi) = 2*mu0*I*i/(3*pi). Note the L cancels, so the answer has no L in it, ruling out options C and D. Answer: A.

Solved Moving Charges And Magnetism NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 30 Moving Charges And Magnetism NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Torque on a Current Loop in a Magnetic Field (tau = m x B)Keep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Moving Charges And Magnetism NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Does the size of the loop appear in the net force?

No, the side length L cancels out. Each parallel side gives force proportional to L/r, and because r itself scales with the geometry set by L, the L cancels. That is why the NEET 2016 answer 2*mu0*I*i/(3*pi) has no L, and any option containing L is wrong.

What if the loop were a rectangle instead of a square?

Same method. Only the two long sides parallel to the wire (length b, say) give a net force. Net force = (mu0*I*i*b)/(2*pi) * (1/r_near - 1/r_far), directed toward the near side. The two shorter perpendicular sides still cancel.

What decides whether the loop moves toward or away from the wire?

The near side, because it feels the stronger force. If the near side current is parallel (same direction) to the wire current, the loop is pulled in. If antiparallel, it is pushed away. This follows the parallel-wire attraction and repulsion rule.

Is there also a torque on the loop here?

If the loop is coplanar with the wire, the field lies in the plane of the loop and gives a net force but the standard torque tau = m x B analysis is for a uniform field; here the field is non-uniform. For NEET, these questions ask only for the net force. Torque in a uniform field is a separate topic.

Why does the far side push the loop away?

On the far side, the current direction is opposite to the near side (it is the return path of the loop). If the near side is parallel to the wire (attraction), the far side is antiparallel (repulsion). So the far side always opposes the near side, but weaker because it is farther, so the near side wins.