Refraction of a Plane Wave Using Huygens Principle (Snell's Law Proof)

Physics · Wave Optics · NEET

When a plane wavefront hits the boundary between two media, one edge crosses first and slows down (or speeds up) while the other edge is still travelling in the old medium. This makes the wavefront turn. Using Huygens principle, sin i / sin r = v1/v2 = n2/n1, which is Snell's law. Memory hook: "the wavefront pivots because one foot walks slower than the other" - like a line of marching soldiers turning when the left side hits mud.
PP'Medium 1 (v1, n1) - rarerMedium 2 (v2, n2) - denserNACB (incident wavefront AB)E (AE = v2 tau)refracted wavefront CEirBC = v1 tau
Incident plane wavefront AB meets boundary PP'. In time tau, B travels BC = v1 tau in medium 1 while A travels AE = v2 tau into medium 2. The tangent plane CE is the refracted wavefront. Dividing sin i = BC/AC by sin r = AE/AC gives sin i / sin r = v1/v2 = n2/n1 (Snell's law).

Your doubts, answered

How is Snell's law derived from Huygens principle step by step?

Take a plane wavefront AB hitting surface PP' at angle i. In time tau, edge B travels distance BC = v1 x tau in medium 1 and reaches C. During the same time tau, edge A enters medium 2 and travels AE = v2 x tau. Draw the refracted wavefront CE. Now in right triangle ABC, sin i = BC/AC = v1 tau / AC. In right triangle AEC, sin r = AE/AC = v2 tau / AC. Divide them: sin i / sin r = v1/v2. Since v1 = c/n1 and v2 = c/n2, this becomes sin i / sin r = n2/n1, i.e. n1 sin i = n2 sin r. That is Snell's law.

Why does the wavefront bend at the boundary?

The two edges of the wavefront do not reach the boundary at the same time. One edge crosses into the new medium first and changes speed, while the other edge is still moving in the old medium at the old speed. Because the two ends now travel different distances in the same time tau, the line joining them (the new wavefront) tilts. Bending happens only because the speed changes, not because the frequency changes.

Why is sin i / sin r equal to v1/v2 and not v2/v1?

sin i comes from the distance the wave travels in medium 1 (BC = v1 tau) and sin r comes from the distance in medium 2 (AE = v2 tau). Both are divided by the same hypotenuse AC. So sin i / sin r = (v1 tau / AC) / (v2 tau / AC) = v1/v2. Careful: in terms of refractive index this flips, sin i / sin r = n2/n1, because n is inversely proportional to speed (n = c/v).

When light goes from rarer to denser (air to glass), does it speed up or slow down?

It slows down. In a denser medium (higher n) the speed v = c/n is smaller. So v2 < v1, which makes sin r < sin i, meaning r < i. The refracted ray bends towards the normal. Huygens' wave theory predicts speed decreases in the denser medium, which matched experiment. Newton's corpuscular model wrongly predicted speed increases, so Huygens was right.

What do AE, BC, tau and AC mean in the derivation?

AB is the incident plane wavefront. tau is the small time taken for edge B to reach the boundary at C. BC = v1 x tau is how far the wave moves in medium 1. AE = v2 x tau is how far it moves in medium 2 (a sphere of radius v2 tau drawn from A). CE is the tangent plane = the refracted wavefront. AC is the common hypotenuse shared by both right triangles, which is why it cancels when you take the ratio.

Why does wavelength change but frequency stays the same in refraction?

Frequency is set by the source and cannot change when light crosses a boundary. Since v = f x lambda and f is fixed, when v decreases in a denser medium, lambda must decrease too. NCERT shows BC = lambda1 and AE = lambda2, and lambda2/lambda1 = v2/v1 = n1/n2. So in glass (n = 1.5), the wavelength shrinks to two-thirds while the colour (frequency) stays the same.

⚠️ The NEET trap
sin i / sin r = v2/v1 (matching it directly to the refractive index ratio n2/n1)
sin i / sin r = v1/v2 = n2/n1. In terms of SPEED the numerator uses v1 (medium 1); in terms of INDEX it uses n2 (medium 2). The two ratios look flipped because n is inversely proportional to v.
🧠 Speed ratio and index ratio are inverses. sin i / sin r = v1/v2 but = n2/n1. Mixing these up is the single most common Huygens mistake in NEET.

Solved Wave Optics NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 22 Wave Optics NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Reflection of a Plane Wave by a Plane Surface Using Huygens PrincipleKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Wave Optics NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What is the final result of Huygens refraction derivation?

n1 sin i = n2 sin r, which is Snell's law. Equivalently sin i / sin r = v1/v2 = n2/n1 = lambda1/lambda2.

Does Huygens principle prove speed decreases in a denser medium?

Yes. The derivation gives v2 = v1 x (sin r / sin i). For air to glass, r < i so sin r < sin i, hence v2 < v1. Light slows in the denser medium, confirming the wave theory over Newton's corpuscular prediction.

Is frequency changed during refraction?

No. Frequency is fixed by the source. Only speed and wavelength change (both drop in a denser medium), keeping v = f lambda consistent.

What shape does the refracted wavefront have for an incident plane wave?

It stays a plane wavefront (CE is a straight tangent plane), but it is tilted at the angle of refraction r to the boundary because the two media have different speeds.

Why does AC cancel in the proof?

AC is the hypotenuse common to both right triangles ABC and AEC. Since sin i and sin r are both measured against the same AC, it cancels when you divide, leaving only the ratio of the distances v1 tau and v2 tau.