Redox Change When Fluorine Reacts With Ice

Chemistry · Redox Equilibrium · NEET

When fluorine gas passes over ice, it gives HF and HOF: H2O(s) + F2 -> HF + HOF. It is a redox reaction because oxygen is oxidised (its oxidation number rises from -2 in water to 0 in HOF) while fluorine is reduced (from 0 in F2 to -1 in HF and HOF). Memory hook: fluorine is so hungry for electrons it even "steals" from oxygen, so oxygen loses and fluorine gains.
F2 + Ice: a Redox ReactionH2O(s) + F2(g) → HF(g) + HOF(g)OXYGEN is oxidisedO in H2O = -2O in HOF = 0-2 → 0 (loses electrons)FLUORINE is reducedF in F2 = 0F in HF, HOF = -10 → -1 (gains electrons)
Fluorine reacting with ice is a redox reaction: oxygen goes from -2 to 0 (oxidised) while fluorine goes from 0 to -1 (reduced). Fluorine is never positive, so oxygen must be 0 in HOF.

Your doubts, answered

Is F2 + ice -> HF + HOF really a redox reaction? How do I prove it?

Yes. Assign oxidation numbers on both sides. In H2O(s): H is +1, O is -2. In F2: F is 0. In HF: H is +1, F is -1. In HOF: H is +1, O is 0, F is -1. Oxygen goes from -2 (in water) to 0 (in HOF), so oxygen is oxidised. Fluorine goes from 0 (in F2) to -1 (in HF and HOF), so fluorine is reduced. Because one element rises and another falls in oxidation number, it is a redox reaction. This is NCERT exercise 7.4.

What is the oxidation number of oxygen in HOF?

In HOF (hypofluorous acid), oxygen is 0. Here is why: fluorine is more electronegative than oxygen, so F takes -1. Hydrogen takes +1. The molecule is neutral, so +1 (H) + O + (-1) (F) = 0, which gives O = 0. This is a rare case where oxygen is neither -2 nor -1. It happens only because fluorine is the one element more electronegative than oxygen.

Why does fluorine attack water instead of just displacing other halides?

Fluorine is the strongest oxidising agent among halogens. It is so reactive that in liquid water it oxidises the oxygen of water itself: 2F2 + 2H2O -> 4HF + O2. Oxygen goes from -2 to 0 (released as O2 gas). Because fluorine attacks water, we do not run fluorine displacement reactions in water solution. Chlorine, bromine and iodine are milder, so chlorine can displace bromide and iodide from their solutions safely.

Why does fluorine give different products with liquid water and with ice?

With liquid water: 2F2 + 2H2O -> 4HF + O2 (oxygen released as O2 gas). With ice (solid, cold water): H2O(s) + F2 -> HF + HOF, where the oxygen ends up in HOF instead of as O2. The cold, solid state slows the reaction and lets the intermediate HOF survive instead of going all the way to O2. Both are redox reactions where oxygen is oxidised and fluorine is reduced.

Is the fluorine-ice reaction a disproportionation?

No. Disproportionation needs the SAME element to be both oxidised and reduced. Here two DIFFERENT elements change: oxygen is oxidised (-2 to 0) and fluorine is reduced (0 to -1). So it is a normal redox reaction, not disproportionation. Do not confuse it with cases like Cl2 + water where chlorine itself both rises and falls.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Writing oxygen as -2 in HOF and then claiming fluorine is +1, so the reaction looks like it is not redox or looks like fluorine is oxidised.
Fluorine is more electronegative than oxygen, so F must be -1. That forces oxygen to 0 in HOF. Fluorine is NEVER positive in any compound. So oxygen (-2 to 0) is oxidised and fluorine (0 to -1) is reduced.
🧠 The HOF oxidation-number trap: students force oxygen to -2 out of habit.

Solved Redox Equilibrium NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 22 Redox Equilibrium NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Predicting Products of ElectrolysisKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Redox Equilibrium NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What are the products when fluorine reacts with ice?

Hydrogen fluoride (HF) and hypofluorous acid (HOF). The balanced equation is H2O(s) + F2(g) -> HF(g) + HOF(g).

What is oxidised and what is reduced in F2 + ice?

Oxygen is oxidised (from -2 in water to 0 in HOF). Fluorine is reduced (from 0 in F2 to -1 in HF and HOF).

Why is oxygen oxidation number 0 in HOF but -2 in water?

In HOF, oxygen is bonded to the more electronegative fluorine, which takes -1. To keep HOF neutral with H at +1, oxygen must be 0. In water there is no fluorine, so oxygen keeps its usual -2.

Can fluorine ever have a positive oxidation state?

No. Fluorine is the most electronegative element, so it always has oxidation number -1 in compounds (or 0 as free F2). This is a fixed NCERT rule and a common NEET checkpoint.

Is F2 with liquid water the same reaction?

The idea is the same (fluorine oxidises oxygen of water), but the product differs. With liquid water you get O2 gas: 2F2 + 2H2O -> 4HF + O2. With ice you get HOF instead of O2.