A Solid Cylinder Floating in Two Layered Liquids

Physics · Mechanical Properties Of Fluids · NEET

When a solid cylinder floats across two stacked liquids, its weight is balanced by the buoyant force from BOTH liquids together. You just add the upthrust from the part in the top liquid and the part in the bottom liquid. Memory hook: "Weight sits on two shoulders" - each liquid layer pushes up on the piece of cylinder inside it, and the two pushes add up to hold the whole weight.
d, LLighter liquiddensity rhoDenser liquiddensity n rhoin denser = pLin lighter = (1-p)LWeight = d L A g (down)Total upthrust (up) = both layers
The cylinder (density d, length L) floats across the boundary: length (1-p)L sits in the lighter liquid (rho) and length pL sits in the denser liquid (n rho). Its weight downward is balanced by the upthrust from BOTH layers added together.

Your doubts, answered

Do both liquid layers really push the cylinder up, or only the bottom one?

Both push up. Any part of the cylinder that is inside a liquid gets an upthrust from that liquid. The lower part sitting in the denser liquid gets a large upthrust, and the upper part sitting in the lighter liquid gets a smaller upthrust. The total buoyant force is the sum of the two. This is why we write weight = (upthrust from bottom liquid) + (upthrust from top liquid).

Why is the buoyant force equal to the weight when it floats?

Floating means the cylinder is in equilibrium and not moving up or down. So the net force is zero. Gravity pulls the whole cylinder down with force weight = d x L x A x g. The two liquids together push it up. For balance, total upthrust must exactly equal the weight. That single balance equation gives you everything you need.

How do I get the fraction of length in each liquid?

Let total length be L and the length inside the denser liquid be pL (with p less than 1). Then the length inside the lighter liquid is the rest, which is (1 - p)L. Each length times the cross-section area A gives the submerged volume in that liquid. You never need the actual value of A - it cancels out because it appears in every term.

Why does the area A and g disappear from the final answer?

Every term in weight = total buoyancy has the same A and the same g and the same L. Weight = d L A g. Bottom upthrust = (n rho)(pL)(A)(g). Top upthrust = (rho)((1-p)L)(A)(g). Divide the whole equation by (L A g) and A, g, L all cancel, leaving only densities: d = n rho p + rho(1 - p).

What if the cylinder were denser than both liquids?

Then it would sink to the bottom and rest on the base, so it would not float freely across the boundary. Floating across the boundary only happens when the cylinder's density d lies between the top density and the bottom density. The lighter liquid alone cannot support it, but the denser liquid at the bottom provides the extra push, so it settles with its lower part in the denser layer.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Only the denser (bottom) liquid provides buoyancy, so d x L = n rho x pL, giving d = n rho p.
Both liquids provide buoyancy. Add them: d x L = n rho x pL + rho x (1-p)L, giving d = rho[1 + (n-1)p].
🧠 Never ignore the top layer. The part of the cylinder inside the lighter liquid still gets pushed up. Forgetting it is the most common wrong answer in this NEET question.

Real NEET questions

2016

Two non-mixing liquids of densities rho and n rho (n > 1) are put in a container. The height of each liquid is h. A solid cylinder of length L and density d is put in this container. The cylinder floats with its axis vertical and length pL (p < 1) in the denser liquid. The density d is equal to:

A · {1 + (n + 1)p} rho
B · {2 + (n + 1)p} rho
C · {2 + (n - 1)p} rho
D · {1 + (n - 1)p} rho
Solution: Floating means weight = total buoyancy. Length pL is inside the denser liquid (density n rho) and the remaining (1 - p)L is inside the lighter liquid (density rho). Let A be the cross-section area. Weight of cylinder = d x L x A x g. Upthrust from bottom liquid = (n rho) x (pL) x A x g. Upthrust from top liquid = rho x ((1 - p)L) x A x g. Set weight = total upthrust: d L A g = (n rho)(pL)A g + rho((1 - p)L)A g. Cancel L, A, g from every term: d = n rho p + rho(1 - p) = rho[np + 1 - p] = rho[1 + (n - 1)p]. So the answer is option D.

Solved Mechanical Properties Of Fluids NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 20 Mechanical Properties Of Fluids NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Why a Pendulum's Time Period Changes When Immersed in LiquidKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Mechanical Properties Of Fluids NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What is the key equation for a cylinder floating in two liquids?

Weight of cylinder = upthrust from top liquid + upthrust from bottom liquid. In symbols: d L A g = rho(top) x (length in top)(A)(g) + rho(bottom) x (length in bottom)(A)(g).

What is the final formula for the density in the NEET 2016 problem?

d = rho[1 + (n - 1)p], where rho is the lighter density, n rho is the denser density, and pL is the length inside the denser liquid.

Does the height h of each liquid matter for the answer?

No. As long as the cylinder floats across the boundary with a known length in each liquid, only the densities and the submerged lengths matter. The given h just tells you the layers are deep enough for this to happen.

Between what values must the cylinder's density lie to float like this?

Its density must be more than the top liquid density rho and less than the bottom liquid density n rho. That is why it settles with part in each layer instead of fully floating or fully sinking.

Why does cross-section area A not appear in the answer?

Because the cylinder has a uniform area A throughout. A multiplies every term equally, so it cancels out when you compare weight with buoyancy. Only lengths and densities survive.