Difference Between Young's, Shear and Bulk Modulus

Physics · Mechanical Properties Of Solids · NEET

All three are elastic moduli (stress ÷ strain), but they describe different kinds of deformation. Young's modulus (Y) is for change in LENGTH (a wire being pulled), Shear modulus (G, also called modulus of rigidity) is for change in SHAPE (faces sliding sideways), and Bulk modulus (B) is for change in VOLUME (uniform pressure squeezing a body from all sides). Memory hook: "Y = long, G = shape, B = volume" — Length, Look (shape), Lump (volume).

At a glance

What changesYoung's Y: length (long dimension)Bulk B: volume of whole body
Type of stressYoung's Y: tensile / compressive (normal, along length)Bulk B: pressure (normal, all-round surface)
Type of strainYoung's Y: longitudinal strain ΔL/LBulk B: volume strain ΔV/V
FormulaYoung's Y = (F/A)/(ΔL/L)Bulk B = −p/(ΔV/V)
Applies toYoung's Y: solids onlyBulk B: solids, liquids and gases
Shear modulus (G) noteShear G: change in SHAPE, stress F/A tangential, strain Δx/L (=angle θ)Shear G = (F/A)/(Δx/L); zero for liquids and gases; controls twisting and springs
Three Elastic Moduli: Three Kinds of DeformationYoung's (Y)change in LENGTHpull downShear (G)change in SHAPEtop slidesBulk (B)change in VOLUMEpressure all sides
Young's modulus governs change in length (pull), shear modulus governs change in shape (top face slides), and bulk modulus governs change in volume (uniform pressure from all sides). All three equal stress ÷ strain, but the stress and strain differ.

Your doubts, answered

How do I tell which modulus a NEET question is asking for?

Look at what is CHANGING. If length changes (a wire is pulled or a rod is stretched) it is Young's modulus. If the shape changes but volume stays the same (top face slides over the bottom face, or a body is twisted) it is Shear modulus. If the volume changes because pressure acts equally from all sides (a body under water or gas pressure) it is Bulk modulus. One quick test: only Bulk modulus involves pressure acting on the whole surface.

Is shear modulus the same as modulus of rigidity?

Yes. Shear modulus and modulus of rigidity are two names for the exact same quantity, symbol G (sometimes written η). NCERT uses G. It is the ratio of shearing stress to shearing strain. So if a question says 'modulus of rigidity', treat it as shear modulus.

Why does stretching a coil spring use the shear modulus, not Young's modulus?

When you pull the two ends of a coil spring, the spring gets longer, but the wire that makes the coil is not stretched along its length — it is TWISTED. Twisting is a shear deformation, so the stiffness of the spring depends on the shear modulus G of the wire material, not its Young's modulus. NEET 2022 tested exactly this idea.

Do liquids and gases have all three moduli?

No. Liquids and gases cannot resist a change in shape, so they have NO shear modulus (G = 0 for an ideal fluid). They also cannot be pulled like a wire, so Young's modulus does not apply. Fluids only resist a change in volume, so they have only a Bulk modulus. Solids have all three.

Which of the three moduli is the largest for a solid?

For most solids there is no single fixed rule, but a common pattern for metals is Y > B > G. Young's modulus and Bulk modulus are usually of similar large size, while the shear modulus is smaller (often roughly one-third of Young's modulus). NEET does not ask you to memorise exact ratios, only to know each modulus and its formula.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Bulk modulus B = F/A ÷ (ΔL/L), same idea as Young's modulus but for volume.
Bulk modulus uses PRESSURE and VOLUME strain: B = −p ÷ (ΔV/V). The stress is pressure p (force per area acting all over the surface), and the strain is fractional change in VOLUME, not length. The minus sign is because volume decreases when pressure increases.
🧠 Do not copy the length formula for volume. Bulk modulus = pressure over volume-strain, with a minus sign. Only Young's modulus uses ΔL/L.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2026

Match List I with List II. List I: A. Young's Modulus B. Compressibility C. Bulk Modulus D. Poisson's Ratio List II: I. (Δd/d)/(ΔL/L) II. FL/(A·ΔL) III. −(1/V)(ΔV/P) IV. −VP/ΔV Choose the correct answer.

A · A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
B · A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
C · A-I, B-IV, C-III, D-II
D · A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
Solution: Young's modulus Y = FL/(A·ΔL) → II (change in length). Compressibility = reciprocal of bulk modulus = −(1/V)(ΔV/P) → III. Bulk modulus B = −VP/ΔV → IV (change in volume under pressure P). Poisson's ratio = lateral strain / longitudinal strain = (Δd/d)/(ΔL/L) → I. So A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I, which is option D.
NEET 2022

Statement I: The stretching of a coil spring is determined by the shear modulus of the material of the spring. Statement II: A coil spring of copper has more tensile strength than a steel spring of same dimensions. Choose the most appropriate answer.

A · Both Statement I and Statement II are correct
B · Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect
C · Statement I is correct and Statement II is incorrect
D · Statement II is correct and Statement I is incorrect
Solution: When a coil spring is stretched, the wire of the coil is twisted (a shear deformation), so its behaviour is set by the shear modulus (modulus of rigidity) — Statement I is correct. Steel has a much higher shear modulus and tensile strength than copper, so a copper spring is weaker, not stronger — Statement II is incorrect. Answer: C. This question rewards knowing that shape-change (twist) uses G, not Young's modulus.
NEET 2017

The bulk modulus of a spherical object is B. If it is subjected to uniform pressure p, the fractional decrease in radius is

A · p/B
B · B/3p
C · 3p/B
D · p/3B
Solution: Bulk modulus B = −p/(ΔV/V), so the fractional volume decrease ΔV/V = p/B. For a sphere V ∝ r³, giving ΔV/V = 3·(Δr/r). Therefore Δr/r = (1/3)(ΔV/V) = p/(3B). Answer: D. This uses bulk modulus (volume change under all-round pressure), not Young's or shear.

Solved Mechanical Properties Of Solids NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 11 Mechanical Properties Of Solids NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Elastic Potential Energy Stored in a Stretched WireKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Mechanical Properties Of Solids NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What is the SI unit of Young's, shear and bulk modulus?

All three have the same SI unit: pascal (Pa) or N/m². This is because each is a stress divided by a strain, and strain has no units, so every modulus carries the unit of stress.

Which modulus applies to change in shape?

Shear modulus (G), also called modulus of rigidity. It measures resistance to a change in shape where the volume stays the same, such as one face sliding parallel to the opposite face.

Can Young's modulus be used for gases or liquids?

No. Young's modulus is for stretching a solid along its length. Gases and liquids cannot be stretched like a wire, so only bulk modulus applies to them. They have no Young's modulus and no shear modulus.

What is compressibility and how is it related to bulk modulus?

Compressibility is simply the reciprocal of bulk modulus, k = 1/B. A material with a high bulk modulus is hard to compress, so it has low compressibility. This link appears directly in the NEET 2026 matching question above.

Are all three moduli defined only within the elastic limit?

Yes. Every elastic modulus is defined as stress ÷ strain in the region where Hooke's law holds, that is within the proportional/elastic limit where stress and strain are proportional. Beyond that the ratio is no longer constant.