Comparing Heat Required for Spheres of Different Radii

Physics · Thermal Properties Of Matter · NEET

For two solid spheres made of the SAME material and heated through the SAME temperature rise, the heat required depends only on their mass, and mass depends on volume. Since volume of a sphere goes as r^3, the heat needed follows Q proportional to r^3. Memory hook: "same stuff, same jump, so heat follows the cube of the radius" - if one sphere is 1.5 times bigger in radius, it needs 1.5^3 = 27/8 times more heat.
Same material, same delta T: heat needed follows r cubedr2Sphere 2 (radius r2)mass ~ r2^3r1 = 1.5 r2Sphere 1 (radius r1)mass ~ r1^3Q1/Q2 =(r1/r2)^3= 27/8
Two solid spheres of the same material heated by the same delta T. Heat needed depends on mass, and mass depends on volume (r^3). With r1 = 1.5 r2, the heat ratio is (1.5)^3 = 27/8.

Your doubts, answered

Why does the heat depend on r^3 and not on r^2 (surface area)?

Heating a whole solid sphere raises the temperature of ALL the material inside it, not just its surface. The amount of material is the mass, and mass = density times volume. The volume of a sphere is (4/3)*pi*r^3, so mass goes as r^3. Because Q = m*c*delta T and only m changes, Q also goes as r^3. Surface area (which goes as r^2) matters for radiation or heat loss from the surface, not for how much heat is stored inside.

Where did the specific heat c go in the ratio?

Both spheres are the SAME material, so they have the SAME specific heat c and the SAME density rho. When you take the ratio Q1/Q2, the c cancels and the rho cancels. What is left is only the volume ratio, which is (r1/r2)^3. That is why the answer is a clean number like 27/8 with no material data needed.

Do I need the same delta T for both spheres?

Yes, that condition is essential. The rule Q proportional to r^3 only holds when both spheres are heated through the same temperature change (same delta T). If the temperature rises are different, you must keep them: Q1/Q2 = (m1*delta T1)/(m2*delta T2) = (r1/r2)^3 * (delta T1/delta T2).

What if the two spheres are made of different materials?

Then you cannot cancel c and rho. Use the full formula Q = rho * (4/3)*pi*r^3 * c * delta T for each sphere and take the ratio. The heat ratio becomes (rho1*c1*r1^3)/(rho2*c2*r2^3) for equal delta T. The clean r^3 shortcut only works when material and delta T match.

Is this about heat capacity or specific heat?

It is about total heat capacity (the heat to raise the whole object by 1 K), which is C = m*c. Specific heat c is per kilogram and is the same for both spheres. But the heat capacity C is bigger for the bigger sphere because it has more mass. So the bigger sphere has larger heat capacity even though the specific heat is identical.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Taking the heat ratio as (r1/r2)^2 because a sphere's surface area is 4*pi*r^2.
Use volume, not surface area. Heat stored goes with mass, and mass goes with volume r^3. So Q1/Q2 = (r1/r2)^3. For r1 = 1.5*r2 this gives (1.5)^3 = 27/8, not (1.5)^2 = 9/4.
🧠 Storing heat = whole volume (r^3). Losing heat from the skin = surface (r^2). NTA loves putting 9/4 as a trap option next to the correct 27/8.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2020

The quantities of heat required to raise the temperature of two solid copper spheres of radii r1 and r2 (r1 = 1.5 r2) through 1 K are in the ratio Q1 : Q2 equal to:

A · 3/2
B · 5/3
C · 27/8
D · 9/4
Solution: Both spheres are copper (same density rho, same specific heat c) and both are heated by the same delta T = 1 K. Heat needed: Q = m*c*delta T. Mass m = rho * volume = rho * (4/3)*pi*r^3. So for same material and same delta T, Q is proportional to r^3. Ratio Q1/Q2 = (r1/r2)^3 = (1.5)^3 = 3.375 = 27/8. Trap: (1.5)^2 = 9/4 uses area instead of volume. Correct answer: C, 27/8.

Solved Thermal Properties Of Matter NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 16 Thermal Properties Of Matter NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: What is Calorimetry and the Principle of MixturesKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Thermal Properties Of Matter NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

What is the formula for heat required to warm a sphere?

Q = m*c*delta T, where m = rho*(4/3)*pi*r^3. Combining, Q = rho*(4/3)*pi*r^3*c*delta T. For the same material and same delta T, this simplifies to Q proportional to r^3.

If radius doubles, how much more heat is needed?

Heat goes as r^3, so doubling the radius (r2 = 2*r1) needs 2^3 = 8 times more heat, assuming the same material and same temperature rise.

Why do bigger objects take longer to heat up?

A bigger object of the same material has more mass, so it stores more heat for each degree (its heat capacity C = m*c is larger). With the same heater power, more required heat means more time.

Does specific heat change with the size of the sphere?

No. Specific heat c is a property of the material only (per kilogram) and does not depend on size or shape. Only the total heat capacity C = m*c grows with size.

When would the ratio be r^2 instead of r^3?

When you compare surface effects like radiated power or surface heat loss, which depend on surface area (r^2). For heat stored inside a solid body, always use volume (r^3).