Cleavage of Ethers and Anisole with HI

Chemistry · Alcohols, Phenols And Ethers · NEET

When an ether is heated with concentrated HI, the C-O bond breaks and you get an alkyl iodide plus an alcohol (or phenol). For anisole (C6H5-O-CH3), you get phenol + CH3I, NOT iodobenzene, because the aryl C-O bond has partial double-bond character and does not break. Memory hook: "Iodine grabs the alkyl side; the ring keeps its oxygen."
Cleavage of Anisole with HIringOstays (aryl-O)CH3breaks (alkyl-O)I- attacks CH3 (SN2)+ HI →OHPHENOL+CH3—Imethyl iodideNo iodobenzene: the ring keeps its oxygen
Anisole + HI: the alkyl C-O bond (red, dashed) breaks and iodide attacks the methyl group to give CH3I, while the aryl C-O bond (green) stays intact, so the ring side becomes phenol - never iodobenzene.

Your doubts, answered

Anisole + HI gives phenol or iodobenzene? Which is correct?

It gives PHENOL + CH3I. Anisole is C6H5-O-CH3 (methyl phenyl ether). The bond that breaks is between the oxygen and the methyl carbon (the alkyl side). Iodide (I-) attacks the CH3 carbon and forms CH3I. The oxygen stays on the benzene ring, so you get phenol (C6H5-OH). You do NOT get iodobenzene, because the aryl C-O bond does not break. This exact question came in NEET 2020 and 2017.

Why does the aryl C-O bond (ring side) not break?

In phenol and anisole, the oxygen lone pair goes into the benzene ring by resonance. This gives the aryl C-O bond a partial double-bond character. A double bond is stronger and shorter than a normal single bond, so it is hard to break. The iodide ion cannot do an SN2 attack on the aromatic carbon either, because the ring is flat and blocks the back-side attack. So iodide always attacks the ALKYL carbon instead.

Which side gets the iodine when both sides are alkyl but different sizes?

For a normal dialkyl ether, iodide attacks the SMALLER (less bulky, less substituted) alkyl group by SN2. Example: for CH3-O-C2H5, you get CH3I + C2H5OH, because iodide prefers the less hindered methyl carbon. BUT if one group is a tertiary (3 degree) group like tert-butyl, the rule flips: the tert-butyl side leaves as a stable 3 degree carbocation (SN1) and picks up iodide to give tert-butyl iodide. So bulky tertiary groups follow SN1, small groups follow SN2.

What is the full mechanism step by step?

Step 1: The ether oxygen is protonated by HI to form an oxonium ion (positive oxygen). This makes the leaving group better. Step 2: Iodide (a good nucleophile) attacks the less substituted carbon by SN2 and pushes out an alcohol molecule. This gives one alkyl iodide + one alcohol. Order of reactivity of acids: HI > HBr > HCl (HI works best). The reaction needs concentrated HI at high temperature.

What happens with EXCESS HI? Do I get two iodides?

Yes. With limited HI you get one alkyl iodide + one alcohol. But with EXCESS HI, the alcohol formed also reacts further with HI and turns into a second alkyl iodide. Example: propyl tert-butyl ether + excess HI gives 1-iodopropane + tert-butyl iodide (both iodides). Exception: if the alcohol is PHENOL (from an aryl ether), phenol does NOT react further with HI, so phenol stays as phenol. That is why anisole always gives phenol, never iodobenzene, even with excess HI.

Benzyl phenyl ether + HI: what are the products?

C6H5-CH2-O-C6H5 gives benzyl iodide (C6H5CH2I) + phenol (C6H5OH). The molecule has one alkyl-type carbon (the benzylic CH2) and one aryl carbon (the ring). Iodide attacks the benzylic carbon (alkyl side), so benzyl iodide forms. The aryl C-O bond stays, so the ring side becomes phenol. You do NOT get iodobenzene. This was asked in NEET 2023.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Anisole + HI gives iodobenzene (C6H5-I) + methanol.
Anisole + HI gives PHENOL (C6H5-OH) + methyl iodide (CH3I). Iodide attacks the methyl carbon, and the aryl C-O bond does not break.
🧠 The ring never lets go of its oxygen. Aryl-O stays, so you always get a phenol, never an aryl iodide.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2020

Anisole on cleavage with HI gives

A · C6H5OH + C2H5I
B · C6H5I + C2H5OH
C · C6H5OH + CH3I
D · C6H5I + CH3OH
Solution: Anisole is methyl phenyl ether, C6H5-O-CH3. On cleavage with HI: C6H5-O-CH3 + HI gives C6H5OH + CH3I. The aryl C-O bond is not broken because of its partial double-bond character (oxygen lone pair goes into the ring). Iodide attacks the methyl carbon by SN2, giving phenol and methyl iodide. Note it is CH3I (not C2H5I), because the alkyl group here is methyl.
NEET 2017

The heating of phenyl-methyl ether (anisole) with HI produces

A · Ethyl chloride
B · Iodobenzene
C · Phenol
D · Benzene
Solution: Anisole (C6H5-O-CH3) is cleaved by HI to give C6H5OH + CH3I. The aryl C-O bond has partial double-bond character and does not break; iodide attacks the methyl carbon (SN2). So the products are phenol and methyl iodide. Iodobenzene is the trap answer and is wrong, because the aryl C-O bond never breaks.
NEET 2023 Phase 1

Consider the following reaction and identify the products A and B: C6H5-CH2-O-C6H5 (benzyl phenyl ether) + HI, heat, gives A + B

A · A = C6H5-CH3 (toluene) and B = C6H5-OH (phenol)
B · A = C6H5-CH2OH (benzyl alcohol) and B = C6H5-I (iodobenzene)
C · A = C6H5-CH2I (benzyl iodide) and B = C6H5-OH (phenol)
D · A = C6H5-CH3 (toluene) and B = C6H5-I (iodobenzene)
Solution: In HX cleavage of an alkyl-aryl ether, iodide attacks the ALKYL carbon, never the aromatic carbon (the aryl C-O bond has partial double-bond character). Here I- attacks the benzylic CH2 carbon, breaking the alkyl C-O bond. This gives benzyl iodide (C6H5CH2I) as A, and the ring side becomes phenol (C6H5OH) as B. Iodobenzene is NOT formed.

Solved Alcohols, Phenols And Ethers NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 33 Alcohols, Phenols And Ethers NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Iodoform Test, Phthalein Test and Other Tests for Alcohols and PhenolsKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Alcohols, Phenols And Ethers NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Does anisole with HI give phenol or iodobenzene?

Phenol. Anisole (C6H5-O-CH3) + HI gives phenol (C6H5-OH) + methyl iodide (CH3I). The aryl C-O bond does not break, so iodobenzene never forms.

Which C-O bond breaks in ether cleavage with HI?

The bond on the alkyl (less bulky) side breaks. For an alkyl-aryl ether like anisole, only the alkyl C-O bond breaks; the aryl C-O bond stays because it has partial double-bond character.

Is ether cleavage by HI SN1 or SN2?

Usually SN2 - iodide attacks the smaller, less substituted carbon. But when one group is tertiary (like tert-butyl), that side follows SN1 through a stable 3 degree carbocation.

Which hydrogen halide cleaves ethers best?

HI is best. The order is HI greater than HBr greater than HCl. The reaction needs concentrated HI (or HBr) at high temperature.

With excess HI, does the alcohol convert to an iodide too?

Yes, if it is an alcohol. With excess HI the alcohol reacts further to give a second alkyl iodide. But phenol does not react further, so aryl ethers always stop at phenol.