Why Is the Second Electron Gain Enthalpy of Oxygen Positive?

Chemistry · Periodic Classification Of Properties · NEET

The second electron gain enthalpy of oxygen is positive because the second electron must enter O⁻, which is already negatively charged. A negative electron and a negative ion push each other away, so you must supply energy to force them together — that is why the process is endothermic (positive). Memory hook: "Like charges fight, so you pay energy to make O²⁻."
Adding electrons to OxygenOneutral+ e⁻−141 kJ/molenergy releasedO⁻negative+ e⁻+780 kJ/molenergy absorbedO²⁻repels e⁻1st step: nucleus attracts e⁻ (negative EGH). 2nd step: O⁻ repels e⁻ (POSITIVE EGH).
First electron is pulled in by the nucleus and releases energy (negative). The second electron is pushed away by the already negative O⁻ ion, so energy must be supplied — the second electron gain enthalpy is positive.

Your doubts, answered

Why is the FIRST electron gain enthalpy of oxygen negative but the SECOND is positive?

The first electron is added to a neutral O atom. The positive nucleus attracts this incoming electron, so energy is released — first electron gain enthalpy is negative (exothermic). The second electron is added to O⁻, which is already negative. Now a negative electron is being forced toward a negative ion. They repel each other, so energy must be SUPPLIED. That makes the second value positive (endothermic).

Does 'positive' mean energy is absorbed or released?

Positive electron gain enthalpy means energy is ABSORBED (endothermic). The system must take in energy to happen. Negative means energy is RELEASED (exothermic). So O + e⁻ → O⁻ releases energy (negative), but O⁻ + e⁻ → O²⁻ absorbs energy (positive).

If it needs energy, how does O²⁻ ever form in compounds like MgO or Na2O?

Making the free O²⁻ ion needs energy overall. But in a solid ionic compound, the huge lattice energy released when O²⁻ and metal cations pack tightly into a crystal more than pays back that cost. So O²⁻ is stable inside the lattice, not as a lone free ion.

Is the second electron gain enthalpy positive only for oxygen, or for all elements?

It is positive for essentially all elements. The second electron always has to be added to an already negative ion (like O⁻, S⁻, Cl⁻). Adding a negative electron to a negative ion always faces repulsion, so the second electron gain enthalpy is always positive (endothermic), whatever the element.

Why do we still write O²⁻ if forming it costs energy?

O²⁻ does exist — but only where lattice energy or hydration energy pays for it. NCERT wants you to know that the ISOLATED gas-phase step O⁻(g) + e⁻ → O²⁻(g) is endothermic. The final compound is stable for a different reason (crystal lattice), not because the second electron was easy to add.

How is this different from ionization enthalpy?

Ionization enthalpy is the energy to REMOVE an electron (always positive). Electron gain enthalpy is the energy change when you ADD an electron. The first one added can release energy (negative), but the second one added to a now-negative ion needs energy (positive).

⚠️ The NEET trap
The second electron gain enthalpy of oxygen is negative, just smaller than the first.
The second electron gain enthalpy of oxygen is POSITIVE (endothermic) because the incoming electron is repelled by the already negative O⁻ ion.
🧠 NTA loves the sign trap: first EGH of O is negative, second is POSITIVE. Not 'less negative' — actually positive.

Solved Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 28 Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Why O and F Have Less Negative Electron Gain Enthalpy Than S and ClKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Periodic Classification Of Properties NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Is the second electron gain enthalpy of oxygen positive or negative?

It is positive. Energy must be absorbed to force a second electron onto the already negative O⁻ ion.

Why is the second electron gain enthalpy endothermic?

Because a negatively charged electron is being added to a negatively charged ion (O⁻). Like charges repel, so you must supply energy — this makes the process endothermic (positive).

What is the value of the second electron gain enthalpy of oxygen?

It is about +780 kJ/mol (a positive, endothermic value), while the first is about -141 kJ/mol. NEET mainly tests the SIGN, so remember: first negative, second positive.

If O²⁻ needs energy to form, why is it common in nature?

In ionic solids the large lattice energy released on crystal formation more than compensates for the energy cost of making O²⁻, so the overall compound is stable.

Does this rule apply to sulphur too?

Yes. The second electron gain enthalpy of sulphur (S⁻ + e⁻ → S²⁻) is also positive, for the same reason: repulsion between the electron and the negative ion.