Discovery of Electron, Proton and Neutron: Experiments and Charges

Chemistry · Structure Of Atom · NEET

The electron was found by J.J. Thomson using cathode rays, the proton was found by Goldstein using anode (canal) rays, and the neutron was found by James Chadwick. The electron is negative, the proton is positive, and the neutron has no charge. Memory hook: "Elephants Play Nicely" = Electron (Thomson), Proton (Goldstein), Neutron (Chadwick).
Discovery of Subatomic ParticlesElectron (e-)J.J. Thomson (1897)Cathode raysCharge: -1e/m same for all gasesmass ~9.1x10^-31 kgProton (p+)Goldstein (anode rays)Positive ion of HCharge: +1e/m depends on gasmass ~1.67x10^-27 kgNeutron (n)James Chadwick (1932)Be + alpha particlesCharge: 0no charge = late findmass ~1.67x10^-27 kg
The three subatomic particles, who discovered them, the rays or experiment used, and their charge and mass. Note that the electron's e/m is the same for every gas, while proton (anode ray) e/m changes with the gas.

Your doubts, answered

Who exactly discovered the electron, proton and neutron?

Electron: J.J. Thomson (1897) from cathode ray tube experiments. Proton: E. Goldstein (1886) first saw the rays (anode/canal rays), and the positive particle in hydrogen was later named the proton. Neutron: James Chadwick (1932). For NEET, remember Thomson = electron, Goldstein = proton (anode ray), Chadwick = neutron.

What is the difference between cathode rays and anode rays?

Cathode rays travel from the cathode (negative plate) to the anode and are made of electrons. They are always the same no matter which gas is inside the tube. Anode rays (canal rays) travel from the anode side toward the cathode and are made of positive ions. Anode rays DO depend on the gas used, because they come from the gas atoms losing electrons.

Why does the charge-to-mass ratio (e/m) of cathode rays stay the same for every gas?

Because cathode rays are made only of electrons, and every electron is identical. The electron does not come from the gas atoms in a way that changes it. So e/m is a constant (1.758 x 10^11 C/kg) for any gas or any electrode metal. This is the key proof that the electron is a fundamental particle present in all matter. Anode rays are different: their e/m changes with the gas because they are gas ions.

Who measured the actual charge of the electron?

R.A. Millikan measured the charge of a single electron using his famous oil drop experiment. He found the charge e = 1.602 x 10^-19 coulomb (negative). Thomson had only found the e/m ratio; once Millikan gave the charge, the mass of the electron could be calculated (about 9.1 x 10^-31 kg).

Why was the neutron discovered much later than the electron and proton?

The neutron has no electric charge, so it is not bent by electric or magnetic fields and leaves no easy track. That made it very hard to detect. Chadwick found it in 1932 by hitting beryllium with alpha particles, which knocked out a neutral particle with mass almost equal to the proton. For NEET, remember: neutron is neutral and its mass is slightly more than a proton.

How are the charges and masses of the three particles compared?

Electron: charge -1 (1.602 x 10^-19 C), mass about 9.1 x 10^-31 kg (very light). Proton: charge +1, mass about 1.672 x 10^-27 kg. Neutron: charge 0, mass about 1.674 x 10^-27 kg (a bit heavier than a proton). A proton is roughly 1836 times heavier than an electron.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Anode rays (positive rays) have a fixed charge-to-mass ratio just like cathode rays.
Cathode rays (electrons) have a fixed e/m for every gas, but anode ray particles change their e/m with the gas used, because they are positive ions made from the gas atoms. Largest e/m for anode rays is with hydrogen (the proton).
🧠 Cathode = same every time (electron). Anode = depends on the gas.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2020

The number of protons, neutrons and electrons in Lu-175 (atomic number 71), respectively, are:

A · 71, 71 and 104
B · 175, 104 and 71
C · 71, 104 and 71
D · 104, 71 and 71
Solution: For an atom, protons = atomic number Z = 71. In a neutral atom, electrons = protons = 71. Neutrons = mass number - atomic number = 175 - 71 = 104. So protons : neutrons : electrons = 71 : 104 : 71. This directly uses the identity of the three subatomic particles: protons and electrons are set by Z, neutrons make up the extra mass.

Solved Structure Of Atom NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 30 Structure Of Atom NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Atomic Number and Mass NumberKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Structure Of Atom NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Is the electron lighter than the proton?

Yes. The electron is about 1836 times lighter than the proton. The electron mass is about 9.1 x 10^-31 kg, while the proton mass is about 1.672 x 10^-27 kg. Almost all the mass of an atom is in the nucleus (protons and neutrons).

What charge does each subatomic particle carry?

Electron has a negative charge (-1.602 x 10^-19 C). Proton has an equal positive charge (+1.602 x 10^-19 C). Neutron has no charge (it is neutral). Because proton and electron charges are equal and opposite, a neutral atom has equal numbers of both.

What is the difference between Thomson's and Millikan's contribution?

Thomson discovered the electron and measured its charge-to-mass ratio (e/m). Millikan later measured the charge (e) of a single electron with the oil drop experiment. Together, e and e/m gave the mass of the electron.

Why is the neutron important for isotopes?

Atoms of the same element always have the same number of protons but can have different numbers of neutrons. These are called isotopes. So the neutron is what makes isotopes of an element differ in mass. This links directly to atomic number and mass number, the next topic.