Relative Velocity in Lift, Escalator and Bus Problems

Physics · Motion In A Straight Line · NEET

Relative velocity just means: how fast one object moves as seen from another. The one rule you need is v(A relative to B) = v(A) - v(B). Same direction, you subtract; opposite directions, you add (because one velocity is negative). Memory hook: "Same way, take away; face to face, add the pace."
Same direction: SUBTRACT Opposite direction: ADDYou60BusVv(rel) = V - 60 (small, slow pass)You60BusVv(rel) = V + 60 (large, fast pass)Escalator: speeds add -> 1/t = 1/t1 + 1/t2 -> t = t1*t2/(t1+t2)Walk speed L/t1 + step speed L/t2 = combined L/t (t is smaller than both)
Same-direction motion subtracts velocities (slow pass); opposite-direction adds them (fast pass). On an escalator both speeds help, so their reciprocals add and the combined time is smaller than either alone.

Your doubts, answered

When do I ADD velocities and when do I SUBTRACT them?

Always use one master formula: v(A relative to B) = v(A) - v(B). You never truly "add"; you always subtract, but you keep signs. Pick a positive direction first (say, up or right). If A and B move the same way, both velocities are positive, so v(A) - v(B) is a small subtraction. If they move opposite ways, one velocity is negative, so subtracting a negative becomes an addition and the relative speed is large. Example: two buses at 40 and 30 m/s. Same direction: 40 - 30 = 10 m/s. Opposite direction: 40 - (-30) = 70 m/s. This is why an oncoming bus flashes past you but a same-direction bus seems to crawl.

Why does the escalator problem give 1/t = 1/t1 + 1/t2 and not t = t1 + t2?

Because SPEEDS add, not times. When Preeti walks up a moving escalator, her speed relative to the ground is her walking speed PLUS the escalator's speed. Let the escalator length be L. Walking alone: speed = L/t1. Escalator alone: speed = L/t2. Together: L/t = L/t1 + L/t2. Cancel L: 1/t = 1/t1 + 1/t2. This gives t = t1*t2 / (t1 + t2). The trap is adding the times directly; that would make her SLOWER, which is nonsense because both effects help her go up.

Does a dropped coin fall the same in a moving lift as in a lift at rest?

Only if the lift moves with UNIFORM (constant) velocity. Then the lift is an inertial frame, there is no pseudo-force, and the coin falls with the same g over the same height, so the time is identical (t1 = t2). Whether the lift goes up or down does not matter, as long as the speed is constant. It changes ONLY if the lift ACCELERATES: then the effective gravity relative to the lift floor becomes g + a (lift accelerating up) or g - a (lift accelerating down), and the fall time changes.

What is the pseudo force in an accelerating lift and when do I use it?

A pseudo force is a fake force you add ONLY when you sit inside an accelerating (non-inertial) frame like a rising lift. Its size is m*a and it points OPPOSITE to the lift's acceleration. If the lift accelerates upward with a, an object inside feels effective gravity g_eff = g + a (heavier). If the lift accelerates downward with a, g_eff = g - a (lighter); if a = g (free fall) the object floats. For NEET, use pseudo force only when the frame speeds up or slows down, never for constant-velocity lifts.

How do I solve a bus-passing problem where buses pass at different time gaps?

The spacing between buses is fixed: d = V(bus) * T, where T is the launch interval. A same-direction bus overtakes you at relative speed (V_bus - V_you), so the gap it closes is d / (V_bus - V_you) = time gap. An opposite bus meets you at relative speed (V_bus + V_you), giving d / (V_bus + V_you). Write both equations, divide one by the other to cancel d and T, solve for V_bus, then back-substitute. This is exactly the NEET 2025 bus problem worked below.

⚠️ The NEET trap
On a moving escalator, add the two times: t = t1 + t2.
Speeds add, so t = t1*t2 / (t1 + t2), which is SMALLER than both t1 and t2.
🧠 Two helping effects must make you FASTER, so the combined time is less than either time alone. If your answer is bigger than t1 or t2, you added times by mistake.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2017

Preeti reached the metro station and found that the escalator was not working. She walked up the stationary escalator in time t1. On other days, if she remains stationary on the moving escalator, then the escalator takes her up in time t2. The time taken by her to walk up on the moving escalator will be:

A · t1*t2 / (t2 + t1)
B · t1*t2 / (t2 - t1)
C · (t1 + t2) / 2
D · t1 - t2
Solution: Let the escalator length be L. Walking speed = L/t1. Escalator speed = L/t2. On the moving escalator, both help her, so speeds add: L/t = L/t1 + L/t2. Cancel L: 1/t = 1/t1 + 1/t2. Solving, t = t1*t2 / (t1 + t2). Note this is less than both t1 and t2, which makes sense since two effects push her up together. Answer: A.
NEET 2025

Buses leave cities X and Y in both directions at regular intervals of T minutes with the same speed. A girl driving from X to Y at 60 km/h notices that a bus moving in her direction passes her every 30 min, while a bus moving in the opposite direction passes her every 10 min. The interval T and the speed of the buses are respectively:

A · 20 min, 90 km/h
B · 15 min, 120 km/h
C · 10 min, 60 km/h
D · 30 min, 80 km/h
Solution: The spacing between buses is d = V_b * T (V_b = bus speed). Same direction: relative speed = V_b - 60, so d/(V_b - 60) = 30 min = 1/2 h. Opposite direction: relative speed = V_b + 60, so d/(V_b + 60) = 10 min = 1/6 h. Divide the first by the second: (V_b + 60)/(V_b - 60) = (1/2)/(1/6) = 3. So V_b + 60 = 3V_b - 180, giving V_b = 120 km/h. Then d = V_b*T and d/(V_b - 60) = 1/2 gives d = (1/2)(60) = 30 km, so T = d/V_b = 30/120 h = 15 min. Answer: B.
NEET 2019

A person in a lift drops a coin. The coin takes time t1 to reach the floor when the lift is at rest, and time t2 when the lift is moving up with uniform velocity. Then:

A · t1 = t2
B · t1 < t2
C · t1 > t2
D · t1 = 2t2
Solution: Uniform velocity means zero acceleration, so the lift is an inertial frame and there is NO pseudo-force. Relative to the lift floor the coin falls under the same g over the same height h. Using h = (1/2)g*t^2, the time depends only on h and g, both unchanged. Therefore t1 = t2. The answer would change ONLY if the lift were accelerating. Answer: A.

Solved Motion In A Straight Line NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 18 Motion In A Straight Line NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Motion in a Straight LineKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Motion In A Straight Line NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Is relative velocity a scalar or a vector?

It is a vector. In one dimension it has a sign (+ or -) that tells direction. Its magnitude is the relative speed. Always fix a positive direction before plugging numbers into v(A rel B) = v(A) - v(B).

Why does an oncoming train seem so fast but a same-direction one seems slow?

For an oncoming train the velocities are opposite, so relative speed = your speed + its speed (large). For a same-direction train they subtract, giving a small relative speed. Same physics as the bus problem.

In the lift coin problem, does going up versus down matter?

No, not for uniform velocity. Constant velocity in any direction means zero acceleration, so the coin falls in the same time as in a lift at rest. Direction only matters when the lift accelerates.

What is effective gravity in a lift?

When the lift accelerates up with a, effective gravity is g + a. When it accelerates down with a, it is g - a. When it accelerates down at a = g (free fall), effective gravity is zero and objects float. Use this for fall-time and apparent-weight questions.

How important is this topic for NEET?

It appears regularly: NEET 2017 (escalator), 2019 (lift coin) and 2025 (bus interval) all used it. The escalator reciprocal trick and the bus spacing method are high-yield, so memorise both patterns.