Incomplete Octet: Electron-Deficient Molecules (BeCl2, BCl3, BF3, AlCl3)

Chemistry · Chemical Bonding · NEET

Some molecules are stable even though the central atom has fewer than 8 electrons in its outer shell. This happens with central atoms from Group 2 and Group 13 like Be, B and Al. In BeCl2 the Be atom has only 4 electrons, and in BCl3, BF3 and AlCl3 the central atom has only 6 electrons. Memory hook: "Be, B, Al are hungry" — they stay short of 8 and never fully fill their octet.
Incomplete Octet: count electrons around the central atomClBeClBeCl24 e- (2 bonds)sp, linearBFFFBF36 e- (3 bonds)bonds x 2 = electrons
BeCl2 has 2 bonds = 4 electrons around Be; BF3 (like BCl3, AlCl3) has 3 bonds = 6 electrons. Both stay below 8, so the octet is incomplete and the molecule is electron deficient.

Your doubts, answered

How many electrons are around the central atom in BeCl2, BF3, BCl3 and AlCl3?

Count the shared pairs (bonds) around the central atom, each bond gives 2 electrons. In BeCl2, Be forms 2 bonds = 4 electrons. In BF3, BCl3 and AlCl3, the central atom (B or Al) forms 3 bonds = 6 electrons. None of these reach 8, so they all have an incomplete octet. Simple rule: count the bonds and multiply by 2.

Why does BeCl2 have only 4 electrons and not 8?

Beryllium is in Group 2, so it has only 2 valence electrons. It uses both to make 2 single bonds with 2 chlorine atoms. That gives 2 bond pairs = 4 electrons around Be. Be has no extra electrons to make more bonds, so it stops at 4. It stays stable even though its octet is not complete.

Why is boron in BF3 stuck at 6 electrons?

Boron is in Group 13 with 3 valence electrons. It makes 3 single bonds with 3 fluorine atoms, using all 3 of its electrons. That is 3 bond pairs = 6 electrons around boron. Boron has no more electrons and no lone pair, so it cannot reach 8. This is why BF3 is called electron deficient.

What does electron deficient mean?

Electron deficient means the central atom has fewer than 8 electrons in its outer shell, so it is 'hungry' for more electrons. Because of this, molecules like BF3 and AlCl3 act as Lewis acids (electron pair acceptors). BF3 can accept a lone pair from NH3 to form a stable compound. For NEET, remember: incomplete octet = electron deficient = Lewis acid.

Is BF3 electron deficient or does it satisfy the octet by resonance?

By its normal Lewis structure BF3 is electron deficient (only 6 electrons on B). Some books draw a B=F double bond by resonance to complete the octet, but NEET treats BF3 as electron deficient. In NEET 2021 the answer confirmed BF3 has 6 electrons around boron. So for exam purposes, count 6 electrons and call it incomplete octet.

Which molecules are common examples of incomplete octet in NEET?

The four classic examples are BeCl2 (4 electrons), BCl3, BF3 and AlCl3 (each 6 electrons). Also LiCl and BeH2 fit this idea. All have central atoms from Group 1, 2 or 13. These come up directly in 'count the species that do NOT follow octet' questions, so learn them by heart.

How is incomplete octet different from expanded octet?

Incomplete octet means fewer than 8 electrons (BeCl2 = 4, BF3 = 6). Expanded octet means more than 8 electrons (PCl5 = 10, SF6 = 12). Both are exceptions to the octet rule but in opposite directions. In NEET 2023, a single question asked for species NOT having 8 electrons, and the answer mixed both types (AlCl3, BeCl2 short; PCl5 expanded).

⚠️ The NEET trap
BeCl2 has 6 electrons around Be, like BF3 does.
BeCl2 has only 4 electrons around Be (2 bonds), while BF3, BCl3 and AlCl3 have 6 electrons (3 bonds). Do not treat them all the same.
🧠 Group 2 (Be) makes 2 bonds = 4 electrons; Group 13 (B, Al) makes 3 bonds = 6 electrons. Bonds times 2.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2023

Amongst the following, the total number of species NOT having eight electrons around the central atom in its outermost shell is: NH3, AlCl3, BeCl2, CCl4, PCl5

A · 3
B · 2
C · 4
D · 1
Solution: AlCl3 has 6 electrons and BeCl2 has 4 electrons around the central atom (both incomplete octet, electron deficient). PCl5 has 10 electrons (expanded octet). These 3 do NOT have 8 electrons. NH3 (8) and CCl4 (8) satisfy the octet. So the answer is 3.
NEET 2021

BF3 is planar and an electron-deficient compound. The hybridization and number of electrons around the central atom, respectively, are:

A · sp2 and 6
B · sp3 and 8
C · sp3 and 4
D · sp3 and 6
Solution: In BF3, boron forms 3 sigma bonds and has no lone pair, so it is sp2 hybridised (trigonal planar). Three bond pairs give 6 electrons around boron, which is fewer than 8, so BF3 has an incomplete octet and is electron deficient.

Solved Chemical Bonding NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 51 Chemical Bonding NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: Odd-Electron Molecules (NO and NO2)Keep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Chemical Bonding NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

Are incomplete octet molecules stable?

Yes. Even though the central atom has fewer than 8 electrons, molecules like BeCl2, BF3 and AlCl3 are real, stable compounds. They are exceptions to the octet rule but still exist normally.

Why are electron deficient molecules good Lewis acids?

Because the central atom is short of electrons, it can accept a lone pair of electrons from another molecule. This makes BF3 and AlCl3 strong Lewis acids used in many reactions.

Do BeCl2 and BF3 have lone pairs on the central atom?

No. Be in BeCl2 and B in BF3 have no lone pairs on the central atom. All their valence electrons are used in bonding, which is why the octet stays incomplete.

What is the hybridisation of BeCl2 and BF3?

BeCl2 is sp hybridised (linear, 2 bonds). BF3, BCl3 and AlCl3 are sp2 hybridised (trigonal planar, 3 bonds). Both have no lone pair on the central atom.

Is AlCl3 always electron deficient?

Monomeric AlCl3 is electron deficient with 6 electrons around Al. In the solid or vapour it can dimerise to Al2Cl6 to complete the octet, but for NEET counting, treat single AlCl3 as incomplete octet (6 electrons).