Adiabatic vs Isothermal Expansion: Work Done on a p-V Curve

Chemistry · Thermodynamics · NEET

When a gas expands between the same two volumes, an isothermal expansion does MORE work than an adiabatic expansion. In an isothermal process the temperature stays fixed (heat comes in), so pressure stays higher, and its p-V curve lies ABOVE the adiabatic curve. Since work of expansion is the area under the p-V curve, the isothermal path covers a bigger area, so more work is done. Memory hook: "Iso stays HIGH, Adiabat DROPS low, so Iso does more work."
pVA (start)Isothermal (above)Adiabatic (steeper, below)Iso pressure stays higherArea under curve = workLarger area (green) = more work
Both paths start at A. The isothermal curve (green) stays above the adiabatic curve (red) because constant temperature keeps pressure higher. Work equals the area under each curve, so the isothermal expansion does more work than the adiabatic one.

Your doubts, answered

Between isothermal and adiabatic expansion, which one does more work?

Isothermal expansion does more work (for the same start and end volume). In an isothermal process the temperature is held constant, so the gas keeps pulling in heat and keeps its pressure high. Higher pressure at every volume means a bigger push, so more work. In an adiabatic process no heat enters (q = 0), so the gas cools as it expands, pressure falls faster, and less work is done. This is exactly why NEET 2023 states W(isothermal) > W(adiabatic).

Why does the isothermal curve lie ABOVE the adiabatic curve on a p-V graph?

Start both from the same point A. As volume increases, the adiabatic gas cools (temperature drops), so its pressure falls more steeply. The isothermal gas keeps the same temperature, so its pressure falls more gently. At any given volume the isothermal pressure is higher, so its curve sits above the adiabat. The adiabatic curve is steeper because pV^gamma = constant (gamma > 1) drops faster than pV = constant.

Why does the area under the p-V curve equal the work done?

Work in expansion is w = -integral of p dV. Graphically, that integral is just the area under the curve between the initial and final volume. So the process whose curve sweeps the LARGER area between the same two volumes does the maximum work. This is the whole idea behind NEET 2022, which asks you to pick the p-V curve with the biggest area.

Why does a gas cool during adiabatic expansion?

In an adiabatic process no heat is exchanged, so q = 0. By the first law, delta U = q + w = w. During expansion the gas does work on the surroundings, so w is negative, which makes delta U negative. For an ideal gas delta U = nCv(delta T), so a negative delta U means the temperature FALLS. The gas spends its own internal energy to do the work, so it cools.

Is the work sign positive or negative in expansion?

During any expansion the gas pushes outward and does work ON the surroundings, so the work done ON the gas is NEGATIVE (w < 0), using the IUPAC convention. NEET frames this both ways: 'work done by the gas' is a negative value too in their answer keys (see NEET 2019 answer -30 J). Always check whether the question asks work done BY the gas or ON the gas, but the magnitude comparison Iso > Adiabat stays the same.

Does adiabatic mean the same as isothermal free expansion?

No. Adiabatic means no heat flow (q = 0); the temperature usually CHANGES. Isothermal means constant temperature; heat usually flows. They only look the same in one special case: adiabatic FREE expansion into vacuum, where p(external) = 0 so w = 0, q = 0, and delta T = 0 (NEET 2020). In ordinary expansions against a real pressure, adiabatic and isothermal give different work.

⚠️ The NEET trap
Students think the adiabatic gas gets hotter, or that T_C (adiabatic end) is greater than T_A, so they wrongly call 'T_C > T_A' a correct statement.
In a reversible adiabatic EXPANSION the gas does work using its own internal energy, so it COOLS: T_C < T_A. Therefore 'T_C > T_A' is the INCORRECT statement, which is what NEET 2023 asked you to catch.
🧠 Adiabatic expansion = gas spends its own energy = it gets COLDER, never hotter.

Real NEET questions

NEET 2023

Reversible expansion of an ideal gas under isothermal and adiabatic conditions is shown (A to B isothermal, A to C adiabatic on a p-V plot). Which statement is NOT correct?

A · delta S(isothermal) > delta S(adiabatic)
B · T_A = T_B
C · W(isothermal) > W(adiabatic)
D · T_C > T_A
Solution: In reversible adiabatic expansion q = 0, so delta U = w < 0 and the gas COOLS: T_C < T_A. So 'T_C > T_A' is wrong (the answer). The others are correct: along the isotherm T_A = T_B; the reversible adiabat is isentropic (delta S = 0) while isothermal expansion has delta S > 0, so delta S(iso) > delta S(adiab); and the isothermal curve lies above the adiabat, so W(iso) > W(adiab).
NEET 2022

Which of the following p-V curves represents the maximum work done?

A · Curve A
B · Curve B
C · Curve C
D · Curve D
Solution: Work of expansion equals the AREA under the p-V curve between the same initial and final volumes: w = -integral p dV. Among the four paths, the one that sweeps the largest area on the p-V plane does the maximum work, which is curve B. (This is why a higher-lying isothermal path beats a lower-lying adiabatic path.)
NEET 2024

The work done during the reversible isothermal expansion of one mole of hydrogen gas at 25 C from a pressure of 20 atm to 10 atm is (R = 2.0 cal/K/mol):

A · -413.14 cal
B · 413.14 cal
C · 100 cal
D · 0 cal
Solution: For reversible isothermal expansion, w = -2.303 nRT log(P1/P2). With n = 1, R = 2.0, T = 298 K, P1/P2 = 20/10 = 2: w = -2.303 x 1 x 2.0 x 298 x log2 = -2.303 x 2 x 298 x 0.3010 = about -413.14 cal. The negative sign shows work is done by the gas on expansion.

Solved Thermodynamics NEET PYQs

Try the real previous-year questions from this chapter — each with the answer and a full solution.

See all 28 Thermodynamics NEET PYQs ›
Next concept: What is Enthalpy (H)? Heat at Constant Pressure ExplainedKeep learning — 2 minFeeling ready? Solve the Thermodynamics NEET PYQs ›Or practice on your phone — get the free MedicNEET app ›

Frequently asked

For the SAME two volumes, does isothermal always do more work than adiabatic?

Yes, for expansion between identical initial and final volumes. The isothermal curve stays higher (constant T keeps pressure up), so it encloses more area and does more work. Adiabatic cools and drops faster, doing less work.

What is the work formula for reversible isothermal expansion?

w = -nRT ln(V2/V1) = -2.303 nRT log(V2/V1). You can also write it in pressures as w = -2.303 nRT log(P1/P2), since at constant T pressure and volume are inversely related.

Why is delta S = 0 for a reversible adiabatic process?

Because q(rev) = 0 and delta S = q(rev)/T. With no heat exchanged reversibly, the entropy change of the system is zero, so a reversible adiabat is called isentropic. An isothermal expansion instead has delta S > 0.

Is delta U zero for adiabatic expansion?

No. Only ISOTHERMAL expansion of an ideal gas has delta U = 0 (because delta T = 0). In adiabatic expansion the temperature falls, so delta U = nCv(delta T) is negative, not zero.

Why does this matter for NEET?

NEET repeatedly compares isothermal vs adiabatic work, p-V areas, and the sign of delta T. Knowing 'isothermal curve above, more work; adiabatic cools, less work' lets you solve 2022, 2023 and 2024 questions in seconds without long calculation.